Showing posts with label social justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label social justice. Show all posts

Monday, May 18, 2009

time banks



There's been several Hour Currency's the past few decades, perhaps most referenced in america, is Ithaca HOURS. Ithaca HOURs popped up during the early 90s recession (ie, during economically stressed times), and was implemented as a closed and anonymous paper currency.

Time Banks are not all implemented this way. A more modern medium is to do this via the web. Time Banks offers online software to help communities keep track of the hours they share together. As with all other currency efforts i've seen, it's richly steeped in a value system that believes in social equality (note the social justice jargon all over the place on their website).

Interestingly, because their is no monetary value placed on these exchanges, the IRS does not tax transactions. It's placed more in the category of gift economy. perhaps it's a bit of a grey area, as it's a tightly reciprocal gift economy (different than the pay-forward true giving value system of currencies like the giving coins i've blogged about).

I quite like these value systems these groups put forth, though i question their effacy in getting larger economic circles involved in trade with these mediums. Most business and economic spheres are steeped in a division of labor culture that values hours unequally, based on perceived value to the buyer, and what the market price is (ie, the value to the buyer is always higher than the price in the market place, which does sound a bit unfair, doesn’t it?). also, it's a bit hard to measure other forms of capital (like goods) as "labor capital". while it intellectually makes sense, it even makes my own brain hurt a little bit to overload labor with capital. I can see why these social justice people believe there's a conspiracy against labor when power (ie capital) is defined as something that it's not.

anyhow, this floating exchange rate between people's exchangeable hours makes me think about the exchange rates between multiple community currencies and possible private business scripts. I struggle a bit with the loose lexicon of this subject. Changes in community exchange rates (with dollars or other currencies) would basically result in community pay raises or pay cuts (when they are selling their labor/goods), and community buying power increases or decreases (whey they are buying from outside their community system.

This power sharing story already plays out geopolitically between nation-states. I can hear the time hour community railing against the economic injustice of whole groups of people trapped in a currency that relegates their whole nation to sweatshop activity. I cant really blame them for going to the opposite extreme of equality for all. A noble effort, though would need some innovation to bring it out of the fringe.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Social Justice currency being considered in San Francisco


I just met with Heather Young, a San Francisco activist, who is organizing a local currency project. She’s quite a wonderful woman, and is interested in making money have less (what she considers) negative externalities associated with the current dollar economy. She doesn’t say it that way. Who, but an economist, would throw around terms like this?

She wants a currency that promotes social connections, and isn’t controlled by selfish private or large government bureaucratic interests (both of which she believes to have conflicting interests with nurturing community based society). To achieve this, while being sensitive to all the participants values in the forming group, she believes a local cash economy, directed by a civic non-profit, will serve this purpose. Locally produced non-profit money exchanged between the hands of neighbors will promote social connections, and will keep control closer to the people who create the currency.

http://bayareacommunityexchange.ning.com/ , her organization, is this fairly radical and incredibly well intentioned group. I’ll be attending their next currency planning meeting, where they’ll be discussing various cc examples, their underlying values (hopefully coming to consensus on this), and determine next steps. Like many SF radicals, they are coalition builders and are quite interested in networking with other projects. Currency projects included.
Quite an opposite extreme from SDRs!